Marketplace vs own website: which leaves you more profit?

On a marketplace you pay fees on every order, but buyers find you. On your own website the fees are smaller, but you have to bring the buyers. Which pays better depends on one thing more than any other: whether the buyer is new or coming back. Here is how to work it out with your own numbers.

An old brass balance scale on a stone table, with a kraft paper parcel on one pan and a stack of plain coins on the other, beside folded cotton fabric and a notebook
An AI illustration, not a real store or product.

Why isn't revenue the same as profit?

A ₹1,450 order does not put ₹1,450 in your pocket. Before you keep anything, you pay for the product, the box, the platform’s fees, the payment, the delivery, the returns and the ads that brought the buyer. Profit is what is left:

Profit = price − product and packing − fees (with GST) − shipping − ads − returns

Each part is different on a marketplace and on your own store.

What does each cost look like?

CostMarketplaceYour own website
Product and packingYour costYour cost
Platform feesCommission or referral fee, plus fixed or closing fees, with 18% GSTThe store platform’s fee. On ShopNx: ₹0 a month, ₹0 an order
Taking paymentIncluded in the marketplace’s feesYour payment gateway’s fee on prepaid orders, plus GST on it
DeliveryThe marketplace’s shipping fee, or your courier if you ship yourselfYour courier’s rate
ReturnsThe marketplace’s return rules; the cost lands on youYour own return policy; the cost lands on you
Finding buyersThe marketplace’s search, plus sponsored ads if you buy themAll yours: ads, social media, WhatsApp, search
Buyer’s contactStays with the marketplaceYours, so you can sell to them again

What do Amazon and Flipkart charge?

Both publish how their fees work. Neither shows your exact rate without a seller account, so use their pages to understand the parts, and your own seller panel or invoice for the numbers.

Amazon.in

Amazon.in’s fees page, read on 22 November 2026, lists four kinds of fee:

  • Referral fee, a percentage of the price by category, “starts at 0%”. Its own example: an Apparel for Baby item at ₹1,450 and 7% pays ₹101.50.
  • Closing fee, by price band and how the order is delivered, “starts at ₹2”. Its examples run from ₹2 to ₹27.
  • Weight handling (shipping) fee when Amazon delivers, “starts at Rs. 37 per item shipped”. If you ship it yourself, you pay your courier instead.
  • Other fees for storing, packing and removing stock in Amazon’s warehouses.

The page says Amazon adds 18% GST to all of these fees, that the figures are indicative, and that sellers are paid 7 days after an order is delivered.

Flipkart

Flipkart’s fees page, read on 22 November 2026, names two fees: a fixed fee (also called the closing fee), set by your seller tier, and a commission fee by category. It says commission is 0% on all products priced below ₹1,000, whatever the category, and 0% across the whole Fashion category. The full rate card opens in the seller dashboard after you sign up. Check your invoice for GST on the fees.

A worked example

These numbers are assumptions for one example, not any seller’s real figures. Put yours into the calculator below.

  • A baby outfit sold at ₹1,450. The product and its packing cost the seller ₹730.
  • On the marketplace: a 7% referral fee (Amazon’s own example rate for this category), and an assumed ₹90 of closing and delivery fees, all with 18% GST.
  • On the seller’s own store: an assumed 2% gateway fee with 18% GST on it, and an assumed ₹70 courier.
  • Both: an assumed 8 in 100 orders come back, each costing ₹140 in shipping both ways.
  • A new buyer on the own store is assumed to cost ₹250 in ads. A repeat buyer costs nothing to bring back.
One ₹1,450 orderMarketplaceOwn store, new buyerOwn store, repeat buyer
Product and packing₹730.00₹730.00₹730.00
Fees with GST₹225.97₹34.22₹34.22
Courier₹0₹70.00₹70.00
Ads₹0₹250.00₹0
Returns, per order₹11.20₹11.20₹11.20
Profit₹482.83₹354.58₹604.58

In this example the marketplace beats the seller’s own store on a brand-new buyer won with ads, by about ₹128. On a buyer who comes back, the own store keeps about ₹122 more than the marketplace would. That is the real choice: a marketplace is a good place to find buyers, and your own store is a better place to keep them.

Compare with your own numbers

The values filled in are the example above. Replace them with yours.

The order
On the marketplace

Closing or fixed fee, plus the shipping fee if the marketplace delivers.

Only if you ship it yourself.

Sponsored listings, if you run them.

On your own store

From your gateway’s pricing page. 0 for cash on delivery or UPI to your own ID.

Your ad spend ÷ the orders it brought.

Store platform on ShopNx: ₹0 a month and ₹0 an order, so nothing to add.

Per orderMarket­placeOwn, newOwn, repeat
Fees with GST₹226₹34₹34
Returns₹11₹11₹11
Profit₹483₹355₹605
Margin33.3%24.5%41.7%

With these numbers the marketplace wins on a new buyer and your own store wins on a repeat buyer, by ₹122 an order.

Which costs do sellers forget?

  • GST on fees. Amazon.in adds 18% GST to its fees. A 10% commission is really 11.8% of the price.
  • Returns and refused parcels. You pay delivery both ways, and some returns come back unsellable. The COD returns guide works out what refused cash-on-delivery parcels cost, and the marketplace returns guide covers claims for damaged returns.
  • Ads. Divide what you spent on ads by the orders they brought. That is your cost per order, and on your own store it is usually the biggest cost. The ad break-even calculator shows how much you can afford.
  • The payment gateway. On your own store, card and UPI payments through a gateway cost a fee. Cash on delivery and UPI straight to your own UPI ID don’t, but you check those payments yourself. See why stores use a payment gateway.

When does a marketplace make more sense, and when does your own store?

A marketplace fits whenYour own store fits when
You have no followers or buyers yetBuyers already come back, or follow you on Instagram or WhatsApp
People search the marketplace for exactly what you sellYour product is hard to find by search: handmade, custom, local
You don’t want to run ads or post contentYou can post, reply and send links every day
You want the marketplace to handle deliveryYou want your own return policy and the buyer’s contact

Most sellers who do well use both: the marketplace to be found, their own store for repeat orders, bulk orders and their followers. A new website brings no traffic on its own; plan where the first buyers will come from before you build it.

How do you start your own store alongside a marketplace?

  1. Price it. Work out your price for the margin you want with the selling price calculator.
  2. Open a free store and add your best sellers first, with your own photos. The photo resizer makes them one size.
  3. Choose how you take payment: Razorpay, UPI to your own UPI ID or cash on delivery.
  4. Set your delivery rates from your courier’s rate card. The shipping cost calculator helps.
  5. Send your own buyers there: your Instagram bio, WhatsApp status and replies. See selling on Instagram and selling on WhatsApp.

Follow each marketplace’s rules on contacting its buyers. Build your own list from people who find you directly, not from marketplace orders.

Create your free store

Amazon.in’s and Flipkart’s fees are as their public pages showed them on 22 November 2026. Fees change and depend on your category, so check your seller panel before you decide. This is not tax or legal advice.

Questions sellers ask

Is it cheaper to sell on my own website than on Amazon or Flipkart?

Per order, often yes, because there is no commission. But your own website brings no buyers by itself, so you pay to find them, with ads, content or your own followers. Compare the profit on a new buyer and on a repeat buyer: your own store usually wins on repeat buyers.

What fees does Amazon.in charge sellers?

Amazon.in lists a referral fee by category (starting at 0%), a closing fee by price and fulfilment channel (starting at ₹2), a weight handling or shipping fee if Amazon delivers (starting at ₹37 per item), and other fees for its warehouses. It adds 18% GST to all of them and calls the figures indicative.

What fees does Flipkart charge sellers?

Flipkart’s fees page names two: a fixed fee, set by your seller tier, and a commission fee by category. It says commission is 0% on all products priced below ₹1,000 and on the whole Fashion category. The full rate card is in the seller dashboard after you sign up.

Do I need to leave the marketplace to start my own website?

No. Many sellers keep the marketplace for new buyers and use their own store for repeat buyers, bulk orders and their own social media followers.

What does a ShopNx store cost?

Free forever: no monthly fee and no fee on sales. You only pay your own payment gateway, courier, domain and AI providers, directly.